CENTRAL
I observed a man at the Central Library marauding between the shelves and study areas while conducting a mobile phone conversation, speaking continuously.
When I raised this with a female member of staff, I was told there was no specific rule against it and, “hopefully,” it might be quieter upstairs.
I replied that, on this basis, it would also be acceptable for me to take phone calls in the library. Her also-female colleague then chimed in with a brusque, “That won’t help!” Her tone suggested the concern itself – and, by implication, its bearer – had become the problem. Not the disruption which prompted it.
If I dismissed or failed to take a woman seriously in this manner, it would, without question, be interpreted as sexist.
At the same time, a woman nearby was using speakerphone without any intervention from staff. The contrast was noticeable. The application of boundaries inconsistent.
This raises a broader question about what a library is able to guarantee. Can it still function as a reliably quiet environment for reading and study? Or has that expectation, in the postmodern, post-digital age, become conditional? Upon gender?
It also raises questions about how concerns are received. Are they addressed on their merits? Or redirected onto the person raising them? Is there appropriate training for handling such interactions? Is that, too, dependent upon gender? The question of sexism, viewed from every angle, deserves closer examination than is often assumed.
Both exchanges carried a tone. Less receptive. More dismissive. Why not? I am, after all, merely a man. A lesser individual seeking to read or study in a library while claiming the same legitimacy as its female clientele or staff.
It is not as though I were attempting to contribute to a quieter study environment. Or simply to read my book.
“Injustice anywhere is a threat to justice everywhere.”
— Martin Luther King Jr.
#Misandry #Narcissism


Comments
Post a Comment